Finished PPL 2021 - Information and Administrative Decisions

Status
Not open for further replies.

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
PPL.png


Teams/Managers-

Blackthorn Dragoons- Zokuru + Astamatitos
Cinnabar Pyros- ziloXX + Haru
Driftveil Gold Diggers- Vulpix03 + Pasy_g
Fortree Snipers- PabloGarcia + Nalorium
Goldenrod Rollers- Diophantine + Triangles
Mossdeep Supernovas- Mister Tim + Drogba in Shenhua
Saffron Seers- HSOWA + Diego Maradona
Snowpoint Yetis- Christos + ErPeris

Format/Auction Information-

-8 teams, 7 week round robin, cut to top 4 playoffs. No midseason off-week or midseason signups. No trades at any time.

-Extremely inactive/quitting/toxic players may be sold back prior to the end of Week 4 and replaced with an undrafted player from the signups. These transactions require host approval.

-Players have the right to turn down retention offers. Retention prices follow the same formula as in SPL- last year's price +3K or flat 10K- whichever is more. No more than 3 retains per team.

-10 starters and a min of 2 subs per team. Max 16 players per team.

-Formats played are 2x BW OU, 2x DPP OU, 2x ADV OU, 2x GSC OU, 2x RBY OU

-RBY bo3. All other matches bo1.

-120K starting auction credits (minus money spent on retains) per team.

-Auction nom order = reverse of final standings last year. In this case, from first nom to last nom and then snaking back up, it's Gold Diggers, Supernovas, Pyros, Dragoons, Seers, Yetis, Rollers, Snipers.

-As a measure to prevent price fixing, all players may only play tiers they signed up for, with the following three exceptions-

Retained players can play any tier
Players purchased for under 5K in the auction can play any tier
In playoffs, any player can play any tier

-In a playoff tiebreaker, the team with the superior seed will choose two formats (they may choose the same format twice if they wish) and the team with the inferior seed will choose one format

-Auction will be Sunday April 18th at time TBD.

Tournament Schedule-

Week 1-

Yetis vs Pyros
Snipers vs Gold Diggers
Seers vs Dragoons
Supernovas vs Rollers


Week 2-

Seers vs Pyros
Supernovas vs Gold Diggers
Rollers vs Dragoons
Yetis vs Snipers


Week 3-

Rollers vs Pyros
Dragoons vs Gold Diggers
Yetis vs Seers
Supernovas vs Snipers


Week 4-

Gold Diggers vs Pyros
Yetis vs Supernovas
Rollers vs Seers
Dragoons vs Snipers


Week 5-

Yetis vs Rollers
Dragoons vs Supernovas
Gold Diggers vs Seers
Pyros vs Snipers


Week 6-

Gold Diggers vs Rollers
Pyros vs Supernovas
Snipers vs Seers
Yetis vs Dragoons


Week 7-

Snipers vs Rollers
Seers vs Supernovas
Yetis vs Gold Diggers
Pyros vs Dragoons


All artwork created by Brumirage.
Brumirage's Gallery
Brumirage#6041
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
4/12- Snowpoint Yetis have retained Shortage for 15000. They have 105000 auction credits remaining.

4/12- Snowpoint Yetis have retained LuckOverSkill for 12000. They have 93000 auction credits remaining.

4/16- Snowpoint Yetis have retained Melle2402 for 22000. They have 71000 auction credits remaining.

4/16- Fortree Snipers have retained Gacu for 17500. They have 102500 auction credits remaining.

4/16- Goldenrod Rollers have retained Watermess for 10000. They have 110000 auction credits remaining.

4/17- Mossdeep Supernovas have retained Caetano93 for 24000. They have 96000 auction credits remaining.
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
By popular demand here are the unofficial, my personal opinion only, biased, meaningless CALLOUS Power Rankings. I consulted no one and I don't know some of the players and may be wildly off. In other words, take these for what they are- absolutely meaningless and only worth reading for entertainment purposes.

The teams, weakest to strongest in my eyes, are as follows-

8. Blackthorn Dragoons

Blackthorn-Dragoons.png


First of all, none of the teams are bad, and it wouldn't surprise me if this team finished somewhere other than last, but alas, you can't have "power rankings" if you just call it a four or five way tie with all the middle of the pack ish teams. With this team I look at Fakes and I look at Kael, two quality players to be sure, and then I'm genuinely unsure who their third best player is, but whoever it is it's a significant dropoff from the aforementioned power players. Also, if Kael is your second best player, is that truly good enough for a championship push? Fakes at 31K is acceptable in this auction *if* he's going to show up and play all of his matches- far from a certainty- and *if* you're playing him in his best tier, which certainly isn't GSC. For this team to have a shot Fakes will need to play every week and do a whole lot of winning in what is, ultimately, probably his fourth or fifth best tier. If Fakes disappears this team is absolutely doomed. Likewise, A Hero's Destiny, an underrated player who I'm quite fond of, is in my eyes superior in both ADV and BW than he is in DPP, so that's another instance of weird tier slotting and not maximizing the player in my opinion. Devin, SEA, Jaajgko and Mattakata are all serviceable, middling, role-player type of guys that are never going to carry their team but also shouldn't be a liability. Nevertheless, I view most of these guys as 3-4/4-3 type players, which only works out if the team catches the right breaks at the right time. If this is the worst team it isn't miles and miles below all but the top two in my opinion, but I think there simply isn't enough upside here, pending huge overperformances from multiple guys, to cross the finish line.

7. Fortree Snipers

Fortree-Snipers.png


The top three here- Raiza, Gacu and SadisticNarwhal- is definitely very solid, but it's also far from a guaranteed 3-0 or 2-1 on a week in, week out basis. Unfortunately, unless those three are putting up a consistent 2-1 or better, or perhaps sometimes even when they do, I can see it being challenging to find the three or four additional wins required to actually win the week. Shakur is an underrated and solid ADV player who can potentially put up a 4-3~ kind of record, but against opponents like Shortage, Endill, Jabba, Dice and other stronger, more experienced ADV players he will certainly have to catch some breaks in order to do so. Toytean is capable of getting wins but his results are inconsistent and he could just as easily finish 2-5 as he could 5-2. The DPP core here seems on par with or worse than most of the other teams. I have a hard time envisioning the team being carried from this tier. Beraldinhoo is capable of a 5-2~ record, but it's far from guaranteed, and he also sometimes has activity issues. The GSC here, all things considered, is actually reasonable. Egor is an underrated player who can hold his own. However, as with the DPP, while this core can probably keep afloat and not be a blatant liability, I can't envision it being dominant or carrying the team either. For this team to win the top three need to be winning consistently and the other guys need to catch the right breaks at the right time. Stranger things have happened, but I think it'll be a dogfight to scrape together the fifth and sixth win on any given week.

6. Goldenrod Rollers

Goldmiltank.png


The top three here- Eden, Watermess, Thunder Cebra- are all definitely good, but are any of them *fantastic*? Are those three going to 2-1 or better every week, and are those three really truly going to be at an advantage in a playoff tiebreaker situation? Eden in BW feels a bit wasted to me, especially given his price tag. Was he worth what you paid for him if he puts up a 3-4/4-3 type record? Watermess has gotten better and better as time passes, and I'd be shocked if he didn't finish positive, but the ADV pool is solid and he's not a massive favorite, if a favorite at all, on any given week against the other top end pieces of the ADV pool. TC is another player who continues to improve and improve, but RBY is RBY. He, like Watermess, will almost certainly finish positive, but it's also hard to envision a 6-1 or 7-0 type of performance from him that the team very well may need in order to make playoffs. After the big three, there's a lot of question marks. Are CalamityGreed and Zacpz going to finish positive most of the time? How good is Caloom? Are Lighthouses and 64 Squares, while solid enough in their own right, going to carry the team via DPP week to week? Similar to Snipers I think this team will struggle week in and week out to find the fifth and sixth win, especially if their top end isn't going 2-1 or better every time. The role-players on this team will have to really step up and overperform if the Rollers want to repeat their finals run from last year.

5. Cinnabar Pyros

Cinabar-Pyrosv2.png


An imbalanced team with a high ceiling and a low floor, the Pyros are one of the more interesting teams to analyze. The Sabella + Choolio BW core should almost certainly finish positive, even if they don't necessarily dominate, and the same can be said about the very solid Kristyl + ElectricityCat pairing. The ADV, however, while not abhorrent by any means, looks weaker than that of the other teams and will very likely finish negative. Nchmax is talented and up and coming, but he'll likely finish with a middling record, and Pokology is not on the same level as the Watermess, Jabba, Endill, Gacu, Dice, etc type of guys at the top of the pool. He may find himself limping to a 2-5 or 3-4 kind of record. Lord Thorx has definitely gotten better and can get wins in an unexciting GSC pool and Unowndragon in RBY is likely to finish middling or positive as well, giving these guys a clear path to victory on any given week, but there's still some question marks. I haven't even heard of their second GSC or RBY players, respectively. If, hypothetically, they can each finish with 3-4/4-3 kind of record, this team should be in a good place and can easily make a playoff run. If, however, there's a good reason I've never heard of them and they end up being liabilities, especially when I think the ADV as a whole is going to drag the team down, then this team might have too many negatives that drown out the positives to make a true championship run. Unlike the three teams below the Pyros, with this team I can see multiple ways to get to five or six wins on any given week, and as such I expect them to be in the mix throughout the season.

4. Snowpoint Yetis

Snowpoint.png


The Yetis did not have a great draft by any means. This team is where it is because their retains really are that damn good. And they need to be, because while Christos and ErPeris did add more than nothing, with Siglut, Johnnyg2 and Oiseau Bleu all being solid additions that should finish positive, they simply did not add enough. Six of the slots are rock solid and four of them are huge question marks. This kind of team has the potential to be carried hard by its top end or to completely flounder and sink should a portion of the aforementioned six players not perform as expected. Links in BW isn't the worst thing in the world, nor is Egalvanc in GSC, but it's hard to imagine either one putting up better than a middling record (with potential for a less than middling record too) and BlessyZ and Max both feel like near-guaranteed negative finishes. Granted, there's 3-4 negative and there's 1-6 negative. The former might be salvageable but the latter is not. This team doesn't have much in the way of options regarding subbing those players out either, so if the bottom end is getting tossed week in and week out there's little to nothing they can do. At least some of their top end guys (Shortage, Johnny, Luck>Skill) are fairly flexible and can potentially move to another tier to accommodate a struggling weaker player should the need arise. It's hard to go too far wrong when you have three retains that are always going to perform but it's hard not to feel like this team had a significantly better shot to win it all last year than they do this time around.

3. Mossdeep Supernovas

Solep.png


Mister Tim and Drogba in Shenhua drafted themselves a sneaky good squad here, with two huge Russian picks courtesy of Mister Tim in Azazel and Nazip that are both relatively unknown, and therefore inexpensive, but genuinely solid. The Caetano + Azazel BW pair is definitely one of the best BW duos in the tour. Emeral is an SPL level DPP and Nazip will hold his own, again making this one of the better DPP duos in the tournament. The ADV is one of the weaker points of the team. Chino Itsuki is underrated and can definitely get wins, but he won't carry, and their second ADVer is unknown to me, which is almost certainly a bad thing given my familiarity with the ADV playerbase and the overall strength of the pool. I'd assume, possibly ignorantly, this player will finish negative. Oibaf and Rahel is a perfectly respectable GSC duo given the pool. I'd think they'll finish middling or positive. Oibaf in particular has never been someone I've viewed as a world-beating player but he's looking better and better in recent times. Frrf is one of the better RBYs in the tour and should also finish positive. Newalfonquest is not someone I'd be overly comfortable starting in RBY, and I suspect he's in for a rough tour, but overall, save the two slots I've got some serious doubts about (the second ADV and second RBY, respectively), this team is quite solid. Should the two slots I'm iffy about put up middling records, this group is even better than I think it is. I think it's easy to underrate this squad because the average team tour player is likely unfamiliar with half of these guys, but I expect this team to make playoffs and who knows from there...

2. Saffron Seers

alakazam.png


HSOWA had a rock solid draft and has assembled a legitimate championship contender. I'm very much of the mind that bad players hurt teams more than good players help them and this team in my eyes has ten solid, proper mons players who won't drag the team down and zero liability slots. Rokhan + CKW isn't amazing, but it isn't terrible either, and they can both get a handful of wins and keep the team afloat. Luisotte remains perpetually unknown and underrated and will, almost certainly, finish positive, and Jhonx is talented and consistent and should be able to generally keep pace. Dice + Stockings is definitely one the top three ADV duos. They should hold their own without issue, even if they don't dominate. Vanisherrr + Slurmz is likely above the median for GSC duos in this tour and should, once again, finish neutral or better. The RBY here is excellent- Mikmer + Louna is clearly the best RBY duo in the tournament. Louna has a history of dipping out on his team in team tours, which would definitely weaken this team significantly should he do that here, but if he stays engaged and plays his sets every week, this RBY duo is virtually guaranteed to go positive and will carry this team to playoffs. Overall, with four standout players in Luisotte, Dice, Mikmer and Louna, zero blatant liabilities and the ability to win from any tier on any given week, this is undoubtedly one of the strongest teams and one of the favorites. Dice or Louna quitting on the team or the BW underperforming are the two biggest ways I see this team potentially imploding, but I fully expect the Seers in playoffs.

1. Driftveil Gold Diggers

Driftveil-Gold-Diggerspng2.png


Vulpix03 is, in my opinion, the strongest drafter in this tournament and this finished product is exactly the kind of team I'd expect from him. This is just solid all the way around and there are zero liabilities to be found here whatsoever. Juan Juan is a reasonable BW player and Beatiful can tag in off the bench if need be and PkmTrainerBlue, while largely unknown to the community at large, is a sneaky good up and coming BWer who has already defeated SoulWind in tournament play. Max Und Max is another unknown, underappreciated pick. He's the twin brother of Felix and he has all the support he will ever need between his managers, Jabba and Sprinkles all feeding him teams and providing tests. Sprinkles, regardless of your opinion of his personality, is very consistent in side tours, virtually always finishing positive and often putting up X-1 or X-2 type records. He takes side tours very seriously, preps, cares and is a genuinely great team presence. Jabba + Endill is an ADV core of two SPL starters which is, for purposes of this tour, extremely good. It's hard to imagine the DPP or the ADV on this team not finishing positive. TopLel + K3nix is one of the strongest GSC pairings in the tour and should, once again, finish at least neutral if not positive. RampageWebber + Emma is, yet again, just solid, even if they're not the highlight of the team or likely to hard carry. In every single tier, other than *maybe* BW, this team is at or above (in some cases well above) the median for that tier in the tournament. With the amount of talent here and given how well-rounded the team is, especially when considering the amount of liability spots almost all of the other teams have, it's very hard for me to envision the Gold Diggers, last year's last place finishers, not making playoffs or contending for the championship.

Overall-

Top- Gold Diggers, Seers
Middle- Supernovas, Yetis, Pyros
Bottom- Rollers, Snipers, Dragoons

Thanks for reading!
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
W1 Shakur v TreinerOrenge

The game was never played, there’s no evidence of scheduling on either of their walls and neither side has presented me with screenshots of Discord scheduling either. Therefore this is a dead game.
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
W1 Vanisherrr v Fakes

This match occurred and neither side disputes that Fakes won the game. However, the replay was not posted and is evidently lost. This is a “replays are required” tournament. As such, going with the same system we used last year, we will accept this result and Fakes will be credited for the win, but this is the one and only “grace game” for the Dragoons. The next time Dragoons fail to post a replay for a win its result will not be honored.
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
W2 Eden v Devin

This game did in fact happen, and Eden won, but the replay/result were never posted. In line with the Vanisherrr v Fakes ruling from week 1, the result of the game will stand (a victory for Eden and a defeat for Devin) and this will be the one "grace game" for Rollers. The next time Rollers fail to post a replay for a win its result will not be honored.

Here is the replay of the game in question-

[Gen 5] OU replay: Tokyo Prison vs. eden - Pokémon Showdown
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
W2 CalamityGreed v Splash

Originally I had ruled this an activity win for CalamityGreed, but I’ve now received a screenshot of both players agreeing to a dead game. Works for me! This is a dead game.
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
W3 K3NIX v Chio

This game played out to its conclusion and Chio won; however, K3NIX made an insulting and unsportsmanlike remark towards Chio at the end of the game.

Chio won, so of course the result of this game will stand, but K3NIX will receive a forum infraction and a warning and he will be ineligible to play in PPL for one week. Because this decision was made in the middle of Week 4, after lineups (which, in the case of Gold Diggers, includes K3NIX) have already been submitted, he’ll be allowed to play this week as planned. He will serve his one week penalty in Week 5 and will be ineligible to play that week.

To all players- please maintain a certain level of respect and decency towards your opponents, regardless of any frustrating things that may happen in a game.
 

CALLOUS

YouTube.com/CALLOUSnarrates
Emeritus
W5 Unplayed Matches w/o Evidence-

The following games appear to me as unplayed and I've received zero evidence from either party to suggest otherwise. These decisions are subject to change in the next couple days should evidence be provided that one party deserves an activity win, but for now these are dead games-

Splash v Caetano
Lord Thorx vs Fakee
Luchik v 16bit

W5 Unplayed Matches w/ Evidence-

Melle v Jester-

Neither player seemed to put forward a large amount of effort in contacting the other to get this done, but from my understanding Melle put forward actual zero effort whatsoever. Jester at least sent him a friend request and waited for Melle to accept, which he never did. Granted, Jester and his managers could have and should have contacted the opposing managers and given them a chance to figure things out or get a sub, but from my perspective one player put in a small amount of effort and the other put in zero. As such, I rule this an activity win for Jester

Links v TC-

These players actually did contact each other and did schedule but the match did not get played. Logs show that Links said he could play on the weekend and he also offered a five hour time range, not "one day, one time only" as TC had stated. Come match time, neither player messaged each other nor the opposing management. TC claims (and I believe him) that he was on smogtours at the match time and Links was not, but no agreement was made that they'd play on any specific server, and no further effort was made from either player, nor were there any further attempts at communication from either party. In any tour I've ever been a part of when a match is scheduled and someone isn't there (which isn't even clear in this case as the other person may have been available on Discord or on the other server, but they didn't bother to check in with each other) the only way activity can be claimed is if the party who believes their opponent is missing notifies the opposing management and gives them a fair opportunity, generally a half hour, to either find their player or make a sub. This did not occur. I see no grounds here for an activity win as basic protocol and basic attempts at communication around the time of the match were not followed. As such this is a dead game
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top